The Old New England Spite House of Marblehead Mass.

The Old New England Spite House of Marblehead Mass. is the 2016 Halloween special in Season 1.5 of Greater Boston, and the sixteenth episode overall.

Synopsis
The old spite house was originally built in 1716. It was inhabited by two brothers who allegedly hated each other so much that they agreed to never speak to each other again. Thomas, one of the brothers, fell in love with a woman named Agnes and watched her from the house; his brother William met Agnes, spent time with her, and proposed to her.

Just after the wedding, William and Agnes's house burned down, and Agnes became sick. Thomas refused to share his home with them and built an expansion to the house where they could live. Agnes died shortly after she and William moved in.

William became reclusive, never leaving his half of the house. Eventually, Thomas became concerned, but could not enter William's locked-up half of the house. He told William to scratch on the walls when he was ready to talk to Thomas. William said he would and then never spoke to Thomas again. Thomas died, and it was only after this that William began scratching down Thomas's casket.

Cast

 * Narrator - Jon Grilz

Content warnings

 * House fire
 * Death
 * Psychological Horror

Recommendations

 * Small Town Horror
 * Sable
 * Archive 81
 * The Deep Vault
 * The No Sleep Podcast